Duping Lime Crime's Chinchilla with OCC Lip Tars

One of the biggest reasons for snagging the Black and White (Tarred & Feathered) Lip Tars from OCC was to try to dupe Lime Crime's Chinchilla lipstick.  It's a super cool colour you don't really see anywhere else and when I got mine I was a little upset with how dark it actually looked.  Lime Crime's site describes it as a medium grey with lavender undertones. 

I think my dupe matches the picture you see on the Lime Crime website but not the colour in real life.  I'll show you a side by side.

I used 2 big drops of Feathered with a drop of Tarred to get the grey base and added a tiny bit of Katricia for the purple tinge.

Here's my result

^^^Lime Crime's site swatch ^^^

 

No flash  

 Flash

No flash again

Here they are side by side in real life:

My mix on the left, Chinchilla on right

So side by side they look completely different but this was still fun to do.  I think my version matches the site picture better however my skintone doesn't go with such a light colour so I'm kind of glad Chinchilla is darker in real life.  It suits me better.

I think I can make my dupe match if I added a bit more grey but I'm going to leave it for now.